Non-Toxic Plush Dog Toys for Gentle Chewers

Choosing the right plush dog toys shouldn’t feel like a trade-off between softness and safety. Whether you’re looking for plush toys for puppies, dog plushies for gentle play, or a softer option for everyday use, this collection keeps things simple. Made without plastic or synthetic stuffing.

Shop Dog Toys
7 products
Sort by
Sort by
100% Organic Cotton Rope Dog Toy - 5 Sizes | Replay Pets 100% Organic Cotton Rope Dog Toy - 5 Sizes | Replay Pets
Replay Pets100% Organic Cotton Rope Dog Toy - 5 Sizes | Replay Pets
From $15.99
Plush Hemp Dog Toy Bone for Gentle Chewers | Replay Pets Hemp Dog bone with small black and white dog on couch
Replay PetsPlush Hemp Dog Toy Bone for Gentle Chewers | Replay Pets
From $23.99
Hemp & Cotton Cat Kicker Toy for Bunny Kicks | Replay Pets Kitty Oliver paying with the best cat toys - not one, but two organic catnip kickers with taupe.
Replay PetsHemp & Cotton Cat Kicker Toy for Bunny Kicks | Replay Pets
$19.99
Natural Dog Toy Bundle for Cuddles, Fetch and Tugging - For Medium Sized Dogs Natural Dog Toy Bundle for Cuddles, Fetch and Tugging - For Medium Sized Dogs
Replay PetsNatural Dog Toy Bundle for Cuddles, Fetch and Tugging - For Medium Sized Dogs
$70.00
Dog Gift Bundle with Natural Treats & Toys – For Gentle & Cuddly Dogs betterbone for moderate chewers in size small displayed with hangtag on white background.
Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019
The Kind PetDog Gift Bundle with Natural Treats & Toys – For Gentle & Cuddly Dogs
$80.00
6 puppy treats and toys laying flat on the grass Archway single ingredient silver carp dog treat packaging on a white background
Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019
The Kind PetPuppy Gift Bundle with Natural Treats & Toys
$80.00
5 dog toys and treats for medium sized dogs laying on the grass Archway single ingredient silver carp dog treat packaging on a white background
Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019
The Kind PetDog Gift Bundle with Natural Treats & Toys – For Medium Sized Dogs (20-50lbs)
$70.00